Skip to content
REALNEWS HUB

HMRC urged to scrutinise tax implications of Man City case

The Treasury Committee, which is responsible for overseeing HMRC, has urged the body to scrutinise tax implications of the Manchester City verdict.

REALNEWS HUB Newsroom

An empty modern football stadium with blue seats viewed from the stands on an overcast day.
REAL NEWS HUB

A parliamentary committee has called on His Majesty's Revenue and Customs to examine the tax consequences stemming from the Premier League's financial misconduct ruling against Manchester City.

The Treasury Committee, a cross-party panel of MPs responsible for monitoring the UK tax agency, has questioned whether officials have sought access to the unredacted documents referenced in an independent commission's findings. Dame Meg Hillier, who chairs the committee, formally requested reassurance that HMRC recognises the gravity and high public interest surrounding the case.

The intervention follows the decision by an independent regulatory commission, which determined that Manchester City breached league financial rules across multiple seasons spanning from 2009-10 to 2017-18. The panel found that the football club had intentionally inflated revenues via illegitimate sponsorship arrangements with assistance from its ownership, using financial manoeuvres to hide the true scale of liabilities.

Scrutiny on the tax dimension intensified after a report by think tank Tax Policy Associates suggested that Manchester City could owe as much as £12 million in unpaid income tax and National Insurance related to an arrangement involving former manager Roberto Mancini. The report highlighted that accompanying penalty fees could push the total potential liabilities up to £24 million.

Manchester City have consistently rejected the allegations and intend to challenge the verdict through an appeal. Club executives claim that the commission committed significant errors of law and fact, describing the ruling as unsafe.

During the initial hearing, the club maintained that payments linked to Abu Dhabi sponsors were legitimate commercial funds supported at times by state assistance, rather than concealed subsidies from owner Sheikh Mansour's private investment firm, Abu Dhabi United Group. The independent commission dismissed those assertions as untruthful and formulated after the fact to hide the underlying funding scheme.

The broader dispute has also drawn responses from commercial partners. State-owned carrier Etihad Airways, the club's main sponsor, stated that it strongly denies taking part in improper commercial transactions and indicated it is weighing potential legal steps against the Premier League over reputational harm caused by the published findings.

The Premier League has declined to comment on the matter, while City prepare their legal challenge. Separately, government records show that Manchester City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak is registered as a foreign diplomat in the UK, a status that confers legal immunities under the Diplomatic Privileges Act.

Earlier on this story

  1. Man City guilty of 'sham' contracts and misleading accounts
  2. Criminal investigation? Relegation or expulsion? The key Man City questions
  3. Man City guilty of all serious financial breach charges: Premier League
  4. The intricate web Man City spun to con the Premier League
  5. What have Man City been found guilty of doing?
Full coverage: Manchester City financial charges verdict
Explained: catch up on this storyWhy was Manchester City found guilty of financial breaches?An independent commission found Manchester City guilty of widespread financial rule violations between 2009 and 2018. The club has lodged an appeal against the ruling while facing potential punishments ranging from points deductions to expulsion.Read the explainer →

Spotted an error? Report it · Editorial standards · Corrections policy

Source & verification

Verified

Reported from Business.

How we verify and rate stories

Get breaking news alerts and the Morning Briefing

Verified stories in your inbox, every one linked to its sources. All newsletters →

Newsletters

Free. Unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.